Ranking all 65 teams

1. Amherst Sharpshooters
2. BSC Raiders
3. SoHo FC
4. Rogue FC
5. Queenston FC
6. Celtic United
7. Clarence
8. BUSS
9. FC Yemen
10. Yemen Elite
11. East Aurora FC
12. Southtowns Family Practice
13. Rangers
14. Wolfpack
15. Roos FC
16. Buffalo Bantu
17. Panthers
18. BSC International
19. Niagara FC
20. Lykan FC
21. Beast City SC
22. Elmwood Saints FC
23. OP Alliance
24. Williamsville Willies
25. Lakeside FC
26. FC Quake
27. Polonia
28. Amherst Alliance
29. Celtic Hoops
30. SPAL Buffalo FC
31. Catan FC
32. Crimson Fire FC
33. Hamburg Monarchs
34. Tonawanda United
35. RVS United
36. Rampart FC
37. Meerkats
38. LaSalle
39. Buffalo Celtic
40. Pendelton United FC
41. Youngstown Marksmen
42. Dutch
43. DSC Buffalo
44. PLYSA Toros
45. West Side FC
46. Alden
47. FC Yemen II
48. Buffalo Gunners
49. Revolution SC
50. Buffalo Blizzard
51. WNY United Reds
52. Aurora Arsenal II
53. FK Bosna
54. Cheektowaga
55. Devils
56. FC Aftershock
57. Depew Village
58. Stone Jug
59. Ukraine
60. Great White Buffalo
61. Celtic 1888
62. Celtic Classic
63. Haz Benz
64. Nickel City Wanderers
65. Rust Belt United

This is my perception when the team is at or close to full strength with plenty of bodies present:

1. BSC Raiders
2. Clarence
3. Amherst Sharpshooters
4. SoHo FC
5. Celtic United
6. Rogue FC
7. Queenston FC
8. Yemen Elite
9. BUSS
10. Roos FC
11. Southtowns Family Practice
12. East Aurora FC

13. FC Yemen
14. Buffalo Bantu
15. Panthers
16. Rangers
17. Wolfpack
18. OP Alliance
19. Niagara FC
20. Williamsville Willies
21. Elmwood Saints FC
22. BSC International
23. Lykan FC
24. FC Quake

25. Polonia
26. SPAL Buffalo FC
27. Celtic Hoops
28. Lakeside FC
29. RVS United
30. Buffalo Gunners
31. Beast City SC
32. Amherst Alliance
33. Catan FC
34. DSC Buffalo
35. Dutch
36. Pendelton United FC
37. Crimson Fire FC
38. Rampart FC

39. Lasalle
40. Tonawanda United
41. FC Yemen II
42. Youngstown Marksmen
43. West Side FC
44. Alden
45. Buffalo Celtic
46. Meerkats
47. Buffalo Blizzard
48. FK Bosna
49. WNY United Reds
50. Aurora Arsenal II
51. Great White Buffalo
52. Hamburg Monarchs

53. Cheektowaga
54. Revolution SC
55. PLYSA Toros
56. Devils
57. Stone Jug
58. Depew Village
59. Celtic 1888
60. FC Aftershock
61. Celtic Classic
62. Ukraine
63. Haz Benz
64. Rust Belt United
65. Nickel City Wanderers